Erin Foster claims Chad Michael Murray cheated on her with One Tree Hill co-star Sophia Bush

Erin Foster has a bone to pick with ex-boyfriend Chad Michael Murray — two decades after their break-up.

The Barely Famous star responded to gossip site DeuxMoi’s claim that the One Tree Hill alum “cheated on her with Sophia Bush” in 2002 during Thursday’s episode of The World’s First Podcast with sister Sara Foster.

“That is what happened,” Sara alleged.

Erin agreed, claiming, “He definitely did cheat on me with her in, like, a pretty egregious way. While we were living together.”

The 41-year-old sarcastically called the alleged betrayal “pretty cool” before laughing it off.

“I’ve moved on though,” Erin said. “I’m over it now. I mean, just barely. Just barely over it.”

Murray and Bush’s reps have yet to respond to Page Six’s requests for comment.

Erin and the actor dated from 2001 to 2002. One year after they called it quits, Murray, 42, publicly moved on with Bush.

The duo, who co-starred on One Tree Hill at the time, got engaged in 2004 and walked down the aisle the following year.

Murray and Bush, 41, divorced in September 2005 after five months of marriage, with the Gilmore Girls alum moving on with Sarah Roemer. The couple wed in 2015 and share three kids.

For her part, Bush went on to date co-star James Lafferty, Chicago P.D. actor Jesse Lee Soffer and businessman Grant Hughes.

The actress and Hughes, 42, got married in June 2022. Bush filed for divorce in August of the following year.

Page Six confirmed on Tuesday that Bush is dating newly single soccer star Ashlyn Harris, who filed for divorce from wife Ali Krieger in September.

Hughes’ rep told us that he “is supportive of all that makes [his ex-wife] happy and fulfilled.”

While Bush and Harris, 38, have to comment on her budding romance, Krieger’s brother, Kyle Krieger, hinted at infidelity in a since-deleted Instagram comment, claiming “these h*es ain’t loyal.”

This article originally appeared in Page Six and was reproduced with permission

Leave a Comment